#36 Inconsistent behavior: query within existing constraint

open-fixed
chickmarkley
5
2008-01-18
2007-10-07
Steve Toub
No

Searching after selecting facet value
-------------------------------------
Simple search for "cushman" (13,514 records).

Browse by "Collection".

Choose the "moa-mods" facet value (2 records)

Simple search for "cushman" (gives 2 records, when I expected 13,514 records)

Choose the "None" facet. (gives 13,514 records when I expected it to stay at 2 records).

Toggling browse facet
---------------------
Simple search for "cushman" (13,514 records).

Browse by "Collection".

Choose the "moa-mods" facet value. (2 records)

Browse by "Collection". (gives 13,514 records when I expected it should stay at 2).

Discussion

  • Kat Hagedorn
    Kat Hagedorn
    2007-10-25

    • assigned_to: nobody --> chickmarkley
     
  • chickmarkley
    chickmarkley
    2008-01-08

    • status: open --> pending-fixed
     
  • chickmarkley
    chickmarkley
    2008-01-08

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=1814905
    Originator: NO

    I believe this is addressed by the latest version of faceting which provides explicit displays about what facets have been selected and the abililty to remove individual selections

     
  • Steve Toub
    Steve Toub
    2008-01-18

    Logged In: YES
    user_id=1897229
    Originator: YES

    Nocoma looks good.

    Please push the relevant changes to production. At present in production, there is this behavior:

    Simple search for "cushman" (14,438 records).

    Browse by "Collection".

    Choose the "Making of America (MoA)" facet value (gives 14,438 when I expected it should give 2)

    But if you repeat these last two steps immediately:

    Browse by "Collection"

    Choose the "Making of America (MoA)" facet value (now gives 2 as it should)

    ?!?!?!

     
  • Steve Toub
    Steve Toub
    2008-01-18

    • status: pending-fixed --> open-fixed