Dev-PHP and the repositories : How many ?

2006-06-17
2012-12-07
  • From http://sf.net/forum/message.php?msg_id=3783158

    Dev-PHP is one project - with two branches sharing some common components / modules.
    However we're going to build two projects ; is it the right choice ?

     
    • Urs Mäder
      Urs Mäder
      2006-06-18

      should we make three repositories?
      1. devphp editor(and only used components)
      2. devphp ide(and only used components)
      3. all shared components
      what you mean?

       
      • Hi Urs,

        First, i'm not sure
        - that the question has a technical solution and
        - that the question is functionally sane.

        With CVS - we could have 1 repository and 3 modules.
        Is it the same with subversion ?

        You are the only one who compiled both projects.
        According to you, is such a merge interesting ?

         
        • Urs Mäder
          Urs Mäder
          2006-06-18

          in this moment the important difference between the modules from editor and ide is the syneditpart. i find it should be the same code base for synedit and the code should be simple to compile with all modules.
          about modules and subversion i cannot say something - never used. But for me it's not a problem to have 3 repositories.

           
          • Thanks.
            in my opinion we started with two repositories, and it'll be enought. So...
            Wait and see ;)

             
          • YaN
            YaN
            2006-06-19

            Well now!
            The repository is dead, so...

            > ...not a problem to have 3 repositories

            And what about maintenance?

            What you will say about such structure:

            |--3dPartyComponents
            | |
            | |---dev-cpp
            |  ---...
            |
            |--OwnComponents
            | |
            | |---debugger
            | |---classBrowser
            |  ---...
            |
            |--ide
            | |
            | |---data
            | |---source
            |  ---...
            |
            |--editor
            | |
            | |---data
            | |---source
            |  ---...

             
            • > What you will say about such structure :

              I shall say that i'm interested, provided that Urs agrees...

               
              • Urs Mäder
                Urs Mäder
                2006-06-22

                What you will say about such structure:

                |--3dPartyComponents
                | |
                | |---dev-cpp 
                | ---...
                |
                |--OwnSHAREDComponents
                | |
                | |---debugger 
                | |---classBrowser 
                | ---...
                |
                |--ide
                | |
                | |---data 
                | |---source 
                ¦ ¦---non_shared_components
                | ---...
                |
                |--editor
                | |
                | |---data 
                | |---source 
                ¦ ¦---non_shared_components
                | ---...

                should be a folder for shared and not shared components. What you mean?
                other structure is ok for me...
                thanks