CEDET

Hi Kiwon,

   I have made similar small projects in the past, but had no trouble. 
Would it be possible for you to create a .tar.gz of a small sample 
problem that shows the problem for me?  You should be able to say:

make dist

in the created project.

Thanks
Eric

Kiwon Um wrote:
> Dear CEDET:
> 
> This mail is to report a bug in the latest CEDET version (CVS).
> 
> This reports seem to concerned with ede functions. When there are two
> targets in a same directory, some functions do not work correctly. It
> reports an error related to ede-preprocessor-map and
> ede-system-include-path if any cpp file in the project is newly visited.
> 
> Please check this, thanks.
> 
> Sincerely,
>  
>

"Eric M. Ludlam" <eric@...> writes:

Dear Eric:

In the previous time, I reported a bug occuring when multiple targets
share a source file. I'm wondering if you check this.

Thanks.
----
I tested a little bit more about that issue. This error exactly occurs
when a file is included in multiple targets, i.e. if two targets share
one source file, the problem gets troubled. Constructing such project,
closing emacs, and reopening the project, it get the problem what I
mentioned.

Please check this again, if you didn't see it, either, let me make and
send a complete example project.

> Hi Kiwon,
>
>   I have made similar small projects in the past, but had no
> trouble. Would it be possible for you to create a .tar.gz of a small
> sample problem that shows the problem for me?  You should be able to
> say:
>
> make dist
>
> in the created project.
>
> Thanks
> Eric
>
> Kiwon Um wrote:
>> Dear CEDET:
>>
>> This mail is to report a bug in the latest CEDET version (CVS).
>>
>> This reports seem to concerned with ede functions. When there are two
>> targets in a same directory, some functions do not work correctly. It
>> reports an error related to ede-preprocessor-map and
>> ede-system-include-path if any cpp file in the project is newly visited.
>>

-- 
Kiwon Um

Ph.D. student
Interactive 3D Media Lab
Department of Computer and Radio Communications Engineering
College of Information and Communications
Korea University

Tel: +82. 2. 3290. 3577 (office)

Hi,

Thanks for the more detailed description of the problem.  I was able to 
reproduce the bug, and I checked in some fixes to EDE to prevent the 
problem.

For files that are shared, the installed pre-processor map will be for 
the "first" target, whatever that is.  If it matters, it could be made 
to ask which project to derive the preprocessor symbols from.

Eric

Kiwon Um wrote:
> "Eric M. Ludlam" <eric@...> writes:
> 
> Dear Eric:
> 
> In the previous time, I reported a bug occuring when multiple targets
> share a source file. I'm wondering if you check this.
> 
> Thanks.
> ----
> I tested a little bit more about that issue. This error exactly occurs
> when a file is included in multiple targets, i.e. if two targets share
> one source file, the problem gets troubled. Constructing such project,
> closing emacs, and reopening the project, it get the problem what I
> mentioned.
> 
> Please check this again, if you didn't see it, either, let me make and
> send a complete example project.
> 
>> Hi Kiwon,
>>
>>   I have made similar small projects in the past, but had no
>> trouble. Would it be possible for you to create a .tar.gz of a small
>> sample problem that shows the problem for me?  You should be able to
>> say:
>>
>> make dist
>>
>> in the created project.
>>
>> Thanks
>> Eric
>>
>> Kiwon Um wrote:
>>> Dear CEDET:
>>>
>>> This mail is to report a bug in the latest CEDET version (CVS).
>>>
>>> This reports seem to concerned with ede functions. When there are two
>>> targets in a same directory, some functions do not work correctly. It
>>> reports an error related to ede-preprocessor-map and
>>> ede-system-include-path if any cpp file in the project is newly visited.
>>>
>

"Eric M. Ludlam" <eric@...> writes:

> Hi,
>
> Thanks for the more detailed description of the problem.  I was able
> to reproduce the bug, and I checked in some fixes to EDE to prevent
> the problem.
>
> For files that are shared, the installed pre-processor map will be for
> the "first" target, whatever that is.  If it matters, it could be made
> to ask which project to derive the preprocessor symbols from.
>

Hi,

Thanks for your fixes to the problem. But some semantic related
functions do not seem to work well, specifically the
semantic-ia-fast-jump function I broadly use.

In the mode-line, it shows:

   Primary-only method ede-system-include-path called on something not
an object.

Sincerely,

Kiwon Um

Hi,

If you run:

M-x toggle-debug-on-error RET

then it should provide more information about what is going in with a 
backtrace buffer.  That will be helpful to figure out what is going on.

Eric

Kiwon Um wrote:
> "Eric M. Ludlam" <eric@...> writes:
> 
>> Hi,
>>
>> Thanks for the more detailed description of the problem.  I was able
>> to reproduce the bug, and I checked in some fixes to EDE to prevent
>> the problem.
>>
>> For files that are shared, the installed pre-processor map will be for
>> the "first" target, whatever that is.  If it matters, it could be made
>> to ask which project to derive the preprocessor symbols from.
>>
> 
> Hi,
> 
> Thanks for your fixes to the problem. But some semantic related
> functions do not seem to work well, specifically the
> semantic-ia-fast-jump function I broadly use.
> 
> In the mode-line, it shows:
> 
>    Primary-only method ede-system-include-path called on something not
> an object.
> 
> Sincerely,
> 
> Kiwon Um
>

"Eric M. Ludlam" <eric@...> writes:

> Hi,
>
> If you run:
>
> M-x toggle-debug-on-error RET
>
> then it should provide more information about what is going in with a
> backtrace buffer.  That will be helpful to figure out what is going
> on.

Hi,

I post the debugger's error message: 

Debugger entered--Lisp error: (error "Primary-only method ede-system-include-path called on something not an object")
  signal(error ("Primary-only method ede-system-include-path called on something not an object"))
  error("Primary-only method %s called on something not an object" ede-system-include-path)
  eieio-generic-call-primary-only(ede-system-include-path (([object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "test" t "test" "" ... nil ... nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ... nil] [object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "ball" t "ball" "" ... nil ... nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ... nil])))
  ede-system-include-path(([object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "test" t "test" "" ("test.cpp" "fem_test.cpp" "tetrahedron_test.cpp" "Matrix.cpp" "matrix_test.cpp" "fem_utils.cpp") nil ("fem.hpp" "Matrix.hpp" "TetrahedralMesh.hpp" "Tetrahedron.hpp" "Vector3D.hpp" "fem_utils.hpp") nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ("boost_unit_test_framework") nil] [object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "ball" t "ball" "" ("fem.cpp" "Matrix.cpp" "fem_utils.cpp") nil ("Vector2D.hpp" "Vector3D.hpp" "blas_wrapper.h" "pcg_solver.h" "sparse_matrix.h" "util.h" "Tetrahedron.hpp" "TetrahedralMesh.hpp" "Matrix.hpp" "fem.hpp" "fem_utils.hpp") nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ("gsl" "gslcblas" "m") nil]))
  semantic-dependency-find-file-on-path("vector" t)
  semantic-dependency-tag-file(("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>))
  semantic-decoration-on-includes-highlight-default(("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>))
  semantic-decoration-on-includes-highlight(("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>))
  semantic-decorate-add-decorations((("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
  semantic-decorate-tags-after-full-reparse((("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
  run-hook-with-args(semantic-decorate-tags-after-full-reparse (("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
  semantic--set-buffer-cache((("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
  semantic-fetch-tags()
  byte-code("ŠŠ. ˆ*.‡" [semantic-fetch-tags nil] 1)
  semantic-refresh-tags-safe()
  semantic-analyze-current-context(2885)
  semantic-ia-fast-jump(2885)
  call-interactively(semantic-ia-fast-jump nil nil)

--
Kiwon Um

Thanks.  This made it obvious what is going on.  I have checked in a 
change to Semantic to deal with this case.

The solution is a bit simplistic, in that it just chooses the first 
target.  It may not always be correct, but it should at least do 
something useful.

Eric

Kiwon Um wrote:
> "Eric M. Ludlam" <eric@...> writes:
> 
>> Hi,
>>
>> If you run:
>>
>> M-x toggle-debug-on-error RET
>>
>> then it should provide more information about what is going in with a
>> backtrace buffer.  That will be helpful to figure out what is going
>> on.
> 
> Hi,
> 
> I post the debugger's error message: 
> 
> Debugger entered--Lisp error: (error "Primary-only method ede-system-include-path called on something not an object")
>   signal(error ("Primary-only method ede-system-include-path called on something not an object"))
>   error("Primary-only method %s called on something not an object" ede-system-include-path)
>   eieio-generic-call-primary-only(ede-system-include-path (([object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "test" t "test" "" ... nil ... nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ... nil] [object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "ball" t "ball" "" ... nil ... nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ... nil])))
>   ede-system-include-path(([object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "test" t "test" "" ("test.cpp" "fem_test.cpp" "tetrahedron_test.cpp" "Matrix.cpp" "matrix_test.cpp" "fem_utils.cpp") nil ("fem.hpp" "Matrix.hpp" "TetrahedralMesh.hpp" "Tetrahedron.hpp" "Vector3D.hpp" "fem_utils.hpp") nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ("boost_unit_test_framework") nil] [object ede-proj-target-makefile-program "ball" t "ball" "" ("fem.cpp" "Matrix.cpp" "fem_utils.cpp") nil ("Vector2D.hpp" "Vector3D.hpp" "blas_wrapper.h" "pcg_solver.h" "sparse_matrix.h" "util.h" "Tetrahedron.hpp" "TetrahedralMesh.hpp" "Matrix.hpp" "fem.hpp" "fem_utils.hpp") nil nil nil "Makefile" t nil nil ("gsl" "gslcblas" "m") nil]))
>   semantic-dependency-find-file-on-path("vector" t)
>   semantic-dependency-tag-file(("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>))
>   semantic-decoration-on-includes-highlight-default(("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>))
>   semantic-decoration-on-includes-highlight(("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>))
>   semantic-decorate-add-decorations((("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
>   semantic-decorate-tags-after-full-reparse((("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
>   run-hook-with-args(semantic-decorate-tags-after-full-reparse (("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
>   semantic--set-buffer-cache((("_TETRAHEDRALMESH_HPP_" variable (:constant-flag t) nil #<overlay from 568 to 589 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("vector" include (:system-flag t) nil #<overlay from 591 to 608 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Vector3D.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 609 to 632 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("Tetrahedron.hpp" include nil nil #<overlay from 633 to 659 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("sparse_matrix.h" include nil nil #<overlay from 660 to 686 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstL" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 698 to 807 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("calLameConstM" function (:typemodifiers ... :arguments ... :type "double") nil #<overlay from 815 to 946 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>) ("TetrahedralMesh" type (:members ... :type "class") nil #<overlay from 948 to 2989 in TetrahedralMesh.hpp>)))
>   semantic-fetch-tags()
>   byte-code("ŠŠ. ˆ*.‡" [semantic-fetch-tags nil] 1)
>   semantic-refresh-tags-safe()
>   semantic-analyze-current-context(2885)
>   semantic-ia-fast-jump(2885)
>   call-interactively(semantic-ia-fast-jump nil nil)
> 
> --
> Kiwon Um
> 
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> *nnml:mail.emacs
>          2: nnml:mail.misc
>   [ misc -- 1 ]
>          1: nndraft:drafts